I am a Yahoo! fantasy sports loyalist so everything I'm about to say completely constructive:
Nick below is spot on; the background is way too busy. I like the transparency but it does strain the eyes a little bit more than the crisp white background of old. Overall, it LOOKS great, but as far as day to day use goes, i could see it getting a little tiresome. As it currently stands, the "Create a trade" page is still under the old format, and it's just a sharp, easy on the eyes contrast to the new version. The side multiple scrolling items (i.e. the side bars with news headlines, etc) on the new Player Profile pages are pretty distracting/annoying, i've gotta say.
With that being said, I am 100% in agreement with a lot of people on this board: there needs to be an option to be able to switch up themes/color schemes. One of the reason I like Yahoo! sports so much is because of the simplicity of the layout and color schemes... ESPN is way too busy, makes it impossible to do simple tasks, and I overall just do not enjoy the dark color schemes/small text they use. To me, this black/grey theme was trying way to hard to be like ESPN, whereas i think the simplicity of the original Yahoo! layout was what set them apart.
My biggest qualm right now is the added steps in looking at a full player profile/game log. No long can you just click on the name and have their profile pop up... now you get their 'sticky note' update when you click on their name. This needs to be changed back. I'm not retarded but it took me a sadly long time to figure out how to get to the play profile from that sticky note (clicking on their name AGAIN). Why add an extra step to get to the profile?? Short and sweet: click on the sticky note. In-depth: click on the name to get the player profile - it's as simple as that.
By far the biggest setback in this update is the game-log/player profile functionality. This was incredibly disappointing... If i want to look up Matt Forte's 2011 stats/game log:
Old version: click name for profile, click game log, click year.
New version: click name for sticky note pop up, click name again for full profile, click game log, click dropdown menu for year, click desired year, click filter.
That is night and day, and to be honest... i just don't see how that was an upgrade. You added 3 steps into a process that used to be so simple - i don't get it. Please god, change this back.
Lastly: if you're going to put Brandon Funston's 'Big Board' on every league home page as a stock-type watch list, the least you could do is get the guy to update - that part was just kind of pathetic... we've all known about Percy Harvin's hip for over a month - he's not ranked in the top 50 players anymore. Great idea, but if you're gonna do it, why don't you just go that tiny step further and provide information that's actually true.
Oh yea, Brad Evans sucks.
That's all I've got. All in all, i'm a fan of moving forward and making the site more aesthetically pleasing, but so far some of the original simplicity of the original site has suffered... give the users some flexibility and don't shove ESPN's all-dark color themes down their throat.
-Franchise