Good trade for me?

Question

im in a 12 team league my starters r peyton manning marc bulger, larry fitz, roy williams, andre johnson, lawrence maroney, nd brandon jacobs...... My bench is: reggei brown edgerrin james, lamont jordan, charlie frye and vernon morency.... this guy wants 2 trade me ronni brown and jericho cotchery fro reggie brown and edge... should i do it?

Answer 1

No.



Despite some previous statements to the contrary Reggie Brown is not a backup, in fact I might put him in ahead of Andre Johnson. He's the number one target for McNabb who looks like he's going to pick up right where he left off and that means good things for Reggie Brown.



Cotchery is a fringe player and Ronnie Brown isn't going to do much because the there are no wideout weapons and they'll be stacking the box.



Arizona is commited to a more run established scheme meaning good things for edge.



You're team is amazing right now, how you ended up with that kind of a team inb the draft is amazing. Don't change course.

Answer 2

That's not a bad deal. You seem to be pretty strong at QB and RB, but you're giving away a better WR for an OK WR and you're giving away about the same talent in Edge for Brown. I'd say it's pretty fair and you could probably accept it without it hurting your team.

Answer 3

YES....Reggie Brown and Edge are both backups while ROnnie Brown would definitly start and jericho cotchery is a good backup.

Answer 4

Yes take it you already have maroney and jacobs and you get a solid backup plus add a better reciever then your losing

Answer 5

absolutly take this trade before the other guy realizes what he has done!! cotchery is gona have a breakout season and ronnie brown is a solid rb. I would take ronnie brown over the edge, and cotchery over reggie brown. Its a win-win for you. congrats

Answer 6

I wouldn't do it. Miami is a horrible team so Ronnie Brown will struggle, and Cotchery will be just ok. I think Edge and Reggie have a much better upside.

Answer 7

no. james and brown are better at their positions than the other two right now. both brown and cotchery need to grow just a little more.

Answer 8

I think that you should do it. ronni brown is gonna be good. but if you don't do it you are still going to dominate your league with that roster.